Skip to content

Where to find the best butter tarts in Ontario

Looking for the best butter tarts in Ontario? We’ve got you covered!

We’re pretty picky about our Butter Tarts here in Peterborough & the Kawarthas and we’re proud to say, we have some of the best tarts in Ontario! Don’t be tardy to the butter tart party, get started on the Butter Tart Tour today!

Download the Buttertart Tour Map

Here’s an ooey gooey list of places to satisfy your sweet tooth:

  • Country Mart  – 3328 Buckhorn Road, Buckhorn, ON, K0L 1J0 – Directions
  • Swiss Bear Restaurant  – 10330 Highway 28, Apsley, ON, K0L 1A0 – Directions
  • Kawartha Bakery – County Road 18 & Hwy 23, RR1, Lakefield, ON, K0L 2H0 – Directions
  • The Nutty Bean Café – 33 Queen Street, Lakefield, ON, K0L2H0 – Directions
  • Black Honey Desserts  – 217 Hunter Street West, Peterborough, ON, K9H 2L1 – Directions
  • Enticing Cakes – 57 Hunter Street East, Peterborough, ON, K9H 1G4 – Directions
  • The Shed Bakery  – 272 Armour Road, Peterborough, ON, K9H 1Y6 – Directions
  • Whistle Stop Café  – 141 Charlotte Street, Peterborough, ON, K9J 2T6 – Directions
  • Doo Doos Bakery – 187 County Road 28, Bailieboro, ON, K0L 1B0 – Directions
  • Pastry Peddler – 17 King Street, Millbrook, ON, L0A1G0 – Directions
  • Electric City Bread Company – 165 Sherbrooke Street, Peterborough, ON, K9J 2N2 – Directions
  • Fresh Country Foods – 566 Frankhill Road, Peterborough, ON K9J 6X3 – Directions
  • Irish Hills Farm – 12 Rose Island Road, Apsley, ON, K0L 1A0 – Directions
  • South Pond Farms – 1020 Gray Road, Pontypool, ON, L0A 1K0 – Directions
  • Baked4U – 9A – 1837 Lansdowne St. W., Peterborough, ON, K9K 1R4 – Directions
  • The Pin – 302 King St,. Peterborough, ON, K9J 2S5 – Directions
  • Buns & Sweets – 818 Hunter Street East, Bridgenorth, ON, K0L 1B0 – Directions
  • The Bridgenorth Deli – 871 Ward St., Bridgenorth, ON, K0L 1H0 – Directions
  • Beachwood Resort – 3043 Beachwood Dr., Lakefield, ON, K0L 2H0 – Directions
  • Iron Bridge Bakery – 2095 Nathanway Dr., Young’s Point, ON, K0L 3G0 – Directions
  • The Planet Bakery – 374 Water St., Peterborough, ON, K9H 7G5 – Directions
  • Two Dishes Cookshop – 261 Charlotte St., Peterborough, ON, K9J 2V4 – Directions
  • A1 Gluten Free Gals – Saturdays Only at the Peterborough Farmers Market, R.A. Morrow Memorial Park, Peterborough, ON, K9J 0A4 – Directions
Have a sweet tooth?

Indulge along the Kawarthas Northumberland Butter Tart Tour!

For a Unique Butter Tart Tour Experience…Try it by Bicycle!

Experience Cycling in Peterborough & the Kawarthas

Sign up to get interesting news, updates and offers delivered to your inbox from Peterborough & the Kawarthas Tourism.

Back to top